Thread: comments & suggestions.
Results 1 to 15 of 18
Comments or Suggestions appreciated Forum: Show it off!Replies: 2
comments and suggestions please Forum: Show it off!Replies: 2
Critiques/Comments/Suggestions Please Forum: Show it off!Replies: 5
Views and comments and suggestions plz......(ty in advance!!) Forum: Show it off!Replies: 16
Comments and Suggestions Please Forum: Show it off!Replies: 8
11-19-2002, 04:33 PM #1
comments & suggestions.
i recently revamped and redesigned one of my older websites. let me know what you think...
11-19-2002, 07:10 PM #2
The pop-up accompanying the "enter here" page looks like an advertising pop-up. I deleted it immediately without looking at its contents. After cleaning my taskbar, I entered again to discover it was the real page.
2. The "real page" loads as a smaller [b]advertising/banner[/b] type page and shouldn't when the above step is taken care of. (I didn't look inside at the source code.)
3. The images in the right side appear associated with the "more info" links - making the images themselves also clickable would be more user friendly.
4. The same small red text is used for the "more info" links and the "new releases" and "welcome to the new beat" non-links. That will probably confuse first time visitors. Clickable links (URLs) should always stand apart from the rest of the items on the page.
5. The "real page" window appears to be non-resizeable and without the normal user menu items. That appears to be very user unfriendly.
11-21-2002, 05:35 AM #3
Really cool looking site!!
11-21-2002, 02:19 PM #4
I have everything set to kill popups and all I can see is a very bleak looking page with the sitename on it....not cool...you ought to get rid of the popup and the "entry" page.
11-22-2002, 02:24 PM #5
I think the overall design and layout are good. The plan is good.
I have to agreed with all the problems others listed, and add one more. I found loading on the slow side. I have high speed hard-wired internet access.
Another point, those java auto-scroll windows do not work with my mouse wheel. They are great for people who do not have a wheel mouse, but annoying because scroll windows are supposed to scroll with the wheel.
I also tried clicking on non-links because they were the same color as real links.
Fans will accept the longer download times, but potential fans could be lost because of it.
I think your page has style.
12-03-2002, 06:40 PM #6
thank you for all your suggestions and comments.
the red stuff was added very last minute. the original design was all black & white, but a few friends said it could use just a little color. hence the random red, here and there.
i'm not sure what to do about the pop-up thing. i personally don't think they're that bad. although, i do understand the 'auto pop-up' being a pain.
anyway, thanks again!robert koons
12-03-2002, 07:15 PM #7
I think the execution and presentation are quite good although I'll admit it uses some of my least favorite features for a web site (most mentioned elsewhere in the thread).
I agree with the meta-refresh idea...maybe that enter page could be changed to a Page Loading and then pop up the main site window after a few seconds, perhaps after preloading the content.
Like all similar sites I've seen it is slooow. I use a 1.5Mbps downstream so I hate to imagine what it must be like for a dial up connection.
For some reason it appears to be twice as slow in NS7.
I didn't have a problem with a frame around the links using IE6 or NS7.
12-03-2002, 09:49 PM #8
the main problem with the doanload speed is my incredibly terrible server.
i'm working on that though.robert koons
12-03-2002, 09:50 PM #9
Yes , sorry, I should have said I checked file sizes and they seemed ok.
12-04-2002, 02:00 AM #10
nice site. cant tell the links from the red non-links though
12-04-2002, 06:56 AM #11
Sorry, I still can't even get into your site to look. The entry link doesn't work for me.....probably losing about half your visitors with that page.
12-04-2002, 03:56 PM #12
haha, i've used the same pop-up script for the past year. i actually got it from this site (pop up tool maker). kind of a strange coincidence.robert koons
12-05-2002, 12:27 AM #13
Don't know why the "ha ha". I do not allow popups and have several things running at once to defeat them!
I am not alone in this, there are many others who will miss out on your site because of the shortsightness of any webmaster to exclude a portion of the intended audience by using UN-user friendly methods and designs.
12-05-2002, 02:48 PM #14
Slightly off-topic here so a mod may want to post this elewhere....
I don't think there is anything wrong with pop-up ads per se as long as they are relevant and don't appear as soon as you enter a site.
Lets face it, if everyone uses ad blockers and cookie crushers it won't be long before you have to pay to enter most web sites because they deprive web makers the paltry commission paid from sales which help offset the cost of running a site.
I tried using pop up blockers but they all messed up my surfing in one way or another. Some were just bad programs, others stopped java script and DHTML menus from working or blocked sites like pegboy's.
Despite the fact I don't generally enjoy using similar sites to pb's I do like to have the option to decide for myself if the content is worth putting up with a few features I find irritating.
My other gripe about blockers was the use of system resources, especially if running a few different programs aimed at different kinds of ads.
I decided it was a much simpler solution just to choose not to visit sites again if they used pop ups/unders or other features I personally don't like.
12-05-2002, 03:59 PM #15
I was under the impression we were supposed to be helping Pegboy with the usability of his website. What do you find off topic in my post?
I was pointing out that I was not the only one who uses such software and webmasters whose usability depends on popups are losing many visitors who are not able to access his site.
Yes< I agree with you that blocking ads is bad as I too am a publisher and some of my income is from displaying ads, BUT popups are not allowed on my website and there are a growing number of people who are going that route with their sites....get caught in popup hell a few times and you too will start looking for surfing solutions!
Have a nice day,